Book review: India vs Pakistan by Husain Haqqani

India vs Pakistan by Husain Haqqani

This is a fascinating and really quite alarming book. If the political pathologies described by Haqqani are correct – and he has been an advisor to four Pakistani prime ministers as well as a top-level diplomat so he’s a lot nearer the decision makers than most of us – then there really is a genuine risk of the rivalry between Pakistan and India blowing up and even going nuclear. In part, that’s because the rivalry is essentially one way: Pakistan’s military and political elite are obsessed with India while India is much more concerned with its place in the wider world. Pakistan wants parity with India (an impossible ambition given relative populations, sizes and economies) while India wants a seat at the world table.

The rivalry, particularly on the Pakistani side, verges on the pathological. Kashmir might be the ostensible reason but it’s clear the reasons go deeper than that. One Pakistani academic quoted in the book gives perhaps the best answer: “If the Arabs, the Turks, and the Iranians, God forbid, give up Islam, the Arabs still remain Arabs, the Turks remain Turks, and the Iranians remain Iranians; but what do we remain if we give up Islam?” Pakistan is a country in religious and political opposition to India: Muslim and largely governed by an over powerful military as opposed to secular (at least officially) and under civilian rule.

One question that might throw further light on the issue is the different relationship India has with Bangladesh as compared to Pakistan. Both were created as Muslim homelands at Partition and indeed they started off as a single country. Admittedly, the Indian military helped local Bangladeshi militias overthrow the rule of Pakistan, which would certainly help for better relations between the two, but it seems clear that religion is not the sole cause of friction, otherwise we would be faced with similar problems in Bengal.

A fascinating book that fits a lot of insight into relatively few pages.

Book review: Treacle Walker by Alan Garner

Treacle Walker by Alan Garner

Am I the only one who wondered where were his parents? Joe’s that is, not Treacle Walker’s. I like children being free to act in stories, unhindered by the adult world, but Alan Garner loves to boil down his stories to the bones and, sometimes, he boils away a bit too much of the flesh. After all, it would only take a sentence to say that Joe’s parents had been tossed in a bag by the rag ‘n’ bone man, or fallen down a well, or had been eaten by tigers while on safari in India. I know it’s not really relevant to the story, which exists in the intersection between myth, memory and folklore with only the passing nod to everyday life – and there’s nothing wrong with that – but I think that Garner’s best stories tread the line a little closer to everyday life, showing how it’s lined with myth and, sort of, twisted where you least expect it. Still, on the other hand, if I was 89 I’d be pleased to still be writing something like this!

Book review: The Great Gatsby by F Scott Fitzgerald

The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald

What do you after a war that kills millions, followed by a flu epidemic that kills millions more? It’s interesting that, when people faced a similar disaster in the Black Death, it brought forth Boccacio’s tales of wit and lust, the Decameron. In the 1920s, it brought the Roaring Twenties and two completely different takes on the hedonistic pursuit of pleasure and experience that encapsulated the decade: in Britain, Evelyn Waugh wrote Decline and Fall, in America F. Scott Fitzgerald wrote The Great Gatsby.

Decline and Fall is tragedy disguised as farce, The Great Gatsby is farce dressed as tragedy. Which pretty much sums up the difference in attitudes between an empire in decline and an empire on the rise. They are both great books, although The Great Gatsby is probably better while Decline and Fall is definitely funnier. Both should be read to understand the period after the Great War and the mind set that went on to produce our own world. And they’re also just wonderful books!

Staring from the Abyss – Part 3

Staring from the Abyss – Part 3

The third and final part of my new story, Staring from the Abyss, is now up on the Zeo Genesis website. Marius Gwerre is trying to get the man he has been hired to protect to safety on the Abyss Station. But something is after them, something more powerful than even Gwerre could imagine. Read the story here.

The bridge had been breached. Whoever was after Halem had peeled open the most secure space in the Abyss Station as if it was a food can.

That at least answered one question. Only a zeo could do that.

Book review: The Fifth Crusade by Thomas W. Smith

The Fifth Crusade by Thomas W. Smith

This is narrative history as it should be done: a story that’s as compelling to read as any novel but which is nevertheless deeply grounded in the primary sources with the necessary leavening of later scholarly analysis. It’s not actually an easy balance to pull off but Thomas Smith does so masterfully. He sets his stall out in the very first pages where he reconstructs the Crusader assault on a fortified stone tower squatting in the middle of the River Nile, guarding access to the vital port city of Damietta. Smith vividly brings the battle to life, plunging the reader into the reality of crusading, where knights far from home had to adapt to entirely new conditions and challenges. In this case, they adapted by building floating assault stations, lashing together boats and building siege towers on them to allow their knights direct access to the upper storey of the Ayyubid fort.

But not only does Smith bring these campaigning vignettes to vivid life, he also illuminates the context for the calling of the Fifth Crusade, the reasons for its enthusiastic adoption and the complex preparations necessary to transport thousands of knights and their accompanying logistics across Europe and the Mediterranean. Where Smith really shines, though, is in showing how a campaign that started so well slowly fell apart as the result of a cascade of poor decisions, each of little particular importance but ultimately fatal when they came together in the disastrous decision to march south on Cairo.

If you read just one book about the Fifth Crusade, read this one.

Staring From the Abyss – Part 2

Staring from the Abyss

Part 2 of my story, Staring from the Abyss, is now live on the Zeo Genesis website.

What had been a routine bodyguarding job for Marius Gwerre suddenly turns serious as the Abyss Station comes under attack from unknown enemies. You can read it here. And if you haven’t read part 1, that is here.

Here’s a taste of the action:

“What’s going on?” asked Halem. “Is it a flare?”

Marius ran to the crystal dome. He looked out.

There.

A ship, fast burning towards Abyss station. 

But even as he fixed the ship by sight, his feeds flared out again. Whatever this incoming ship was, it was able to blank out sensor arrays. Not many factions were able to do that. 

“What’s wrong?”

Marius turned around to see Warq staring at him.

He gestured out into the black. “We have a visitor.”

Book review: Venice and the Mongols by Nicola di Cosmo and Lorenzo Pubblici

Venice and the Mongols by Nicola di Cosmo and Lorenzo Pubblici

There are books of popular history. There are academic histories. And then there are books that straddle that divide. Venice and the Mongols attempts to do that and almost succeeds. Its success comes through the authors, despite being eminent professors, almost entirely escaping the usual word salad of academic writers, and the excellent translation by Sylvia Adrian Notini. The failure lies in the very specific focus of the book, which is both its strength and its weakness.

As a history of the trade relations between Venice and the Mongol Empire, it will surely become required reading; this is the best sort of forensic historical work, with not only qualitative investigation of the trade in goods as varied wax, dried fruit, wine and slaves, but detailed charts showing the equivalence of various weights and measures between Venice and the Mongol Empire.

However, the detail of the examination, and the breadth of the Mongol Empire, requires of the reader a reasonably thorough understanding of the politics and history of the region from the time of the Mongol invasions through to the rise of the Ottomans – and that’s a long time, a lot of people and quite a few fairly short-lived realms.

One myth that the book lays to rest is the recent notion that Marco Polo fabricated his memoirs, never having travelled further east than Persia. However, Polo’s knowledge of Chinese trading practices, down to specific details of areas as specific as Hangzhou’s tax revenue offices, proves that Polo was, indeed, what he claimed: a confidant and officer of the Great Khan.

This book is also what it claims to be: the best history yet written of Venice and the Mongol Empire.

Book review: Conquest by Ferdinand Addis

Conquest by Ferdinand Addis

There are some books that are defined by their titles. 1984. The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. Guns, Germs and Steel. However, there are others that are undone by their titles and Conquest is one of them. Any reader scanning the bookshelves would think this a detailed account of the Roman conquest of Britain – after all, that’s what it says on the cover! But in fact, the conquest only takes up about a quarter of the book.

A better, but less marketable title, would have been Britain: from prehistory to posthistory by way of the Roman occupation. What Addis does, and does brilliantly, is weave the history of Britain from a time before there was any history (that is, before any local historical records) into the wider history of Europe and then take that through the conquest, the centuries as a somewhat restive Roman province, through to the fall of the western Empire and the arrival of the Anglo-Saxons.

Addis is particularly good at bringing readers up to date with the astonishing results of aDNA testing, which is completely rewriting our understanding of the movements of people in prehistoric Europe. Archaeologists, suspicious of tales of the mass movements of people, have been busily reinterpreting all such migrations as cultural transfers. However, what is now clear is that many of these cultural transformations were indeed the result of one lot of people moving in and kicking out the previous residents: the Beaker folk and the Anglo-Saxons among them.

This is narrative history at its best but don’t believe what it says on the cover: the sweep of this book is truly panoramic, from the end of the Ice Age through to the start of modern Britain, and it deserves the widest readership. Hopefully, the title won’t put potential readers off.

ZeoGenesis – Staring from the Abyss

Rob Turpin’s fantastic illustration for my story.

ZeoGenesis is a new tactical skirmish game set in the universe of the Hundred Suns, where the civilisations of the different systems travel via slipways to the different heliospheres, each committed, to varying degrees, to either the philosophy of the Hegemony, which seeks to unify the Humanverse under a single government, or the more anarchistic Accord, who want to let each heliosphere develop according to their own lights, despite the fracturing this will cause.

Most of humanity’s material needs have been met through Z-technology but this has also spawned a new style of combat: Zeoforms, big armoured suits that their operators control through the Kanai-Edelman Bridge, which provides for direct mental control of the Zeoform. These are fast, tough, rugged battle suits that work at speeds far beyond normal human capacity.

As yet, both sides avoid outright war but there are skirmishes, raids and other provocations as each try to enhance their control. But there are other powers at work of which neither the Hegemony nor the Accord are entirely aware. These include the Fleet, the ancient fleet that piloted humanity, on the run from both an alien civilisation and a devouring AI superintelligence, to the Hundred Suns, and the benign superintelligence that seeks to guard and hide humanity from the powers that would destroy it.

For a thousand years, humanity has lived in relative peace, safe among the Hundred Suns. But now people are beginning to think that the Hundred Suns are not so much a refuge as a prison, while distant rumours tell of things beyond imagining searching for the location of the Hundred Suns.

It’s a truly fascinating setting and it’s a great pleasure to write a story (hopefully the first of many) set in this universe. The game was designed by Andy Chambers and the lore is by the great Gav Thorpe, one of the most legendary names in game designing.

My story is called Staring From the Abyss and here’s the beginning:

Marius Gwerre, bodyguard to the rich and occasionally the famous, looked up at the crystal dome. Beyond, the stars spread across the void. They were turning, slowly, gently, in a vast circular dance as the abyss station danced, too, spinning slowly on its axis while it orbited the Pinnacle slip point. 

“This is so…so real.” 

Gwerre looked down from the wheeling stars to the man who was speaking. Warq Halem. The man whom he had been employed to protect by Halem’s clan family. 

And the question occurred to him: Why?

Gwerre watched as Halem’s commentary, relayed through his feeds, brought an answering chorus of real-time responses. Yes, it was true, the man had his followers, but anyone with a crackpot theory and a loud enough voice could always attract a following. It still didn’t seem sufficient reason for Halem’s clan family to have contracted Gwerre as close protection.

To read the rest (this is part 1), go here: https://www.zeogenesis.com/setting/staring-from-the-abyss-part-1

Book review: Bunnyman by Will Sergeant

Bunnyman by Will Sergeant

Will Sergeant is a few years older than me and he played guitar in Echo and the Bunnymen, one of the bands that formed the sonic accompaniment as I sat in my teenage bedroom, drowning myself in teenage angst, ambitions and anxieties. At that age, music has a greater impact than at any other stage in life and the Bunnymen were one of the key influences in what I became. What’s more, I went to a lot of gigs when I was young and among those were some key Bunnymen concerts, including their legendary show at the Royal Albert Hall in 1984. So when I saw that Will Sergeant, of the fringe and the scowl and the jagged guitar, had written a memoir of his life as a Bunnyman, I wanted to read it – particularly as Sergeant wasn’t himself a particular hero. I would fight shy of reading the autobiography of my real musical heroes for fear that they would reveal the boots of clay, and the personal failings, that underlay their music. But Sergeant wasn’t Mac: he was the guy standing beside him on stage. It would be safe to read his memoir.

And indeed it was. This was an entertaining foray down shared experiences of growing up in the sixties and seventies: the bombed-out sites left over from World War II, the grey estates, the poor food, the general lack of supervision, the sudden crazes, from clackers to chopper bikes, and the appalling treatment by teachers in schools. It brought it all back.

Then Sergeant met the rest of the Bunnymen – well, apart from drummer Pete de Freitas, whose job was originally taken by a drum machine. It’s notable how things fell into place for the Bunnymen, who benefited from being in the right place at the right time, as well as interesting gossip on how the other Liverpool bands of the late 70s and early 80s, particularly how Julian Cope formed Teardrop Explodes.

There’s remarkably little rock ‘n’ roll excess – some desultory drug taking but really what comes through most strongly is how set on being cool Sergeant and the Bunnymen were – and how they succeeded.

It’s an enjoyable story that’s competently written, rather like listening to Sergeant reminisce at the pub.