Book review: Between Two Rivers by Moudhy Al-Rashid

Between Two Rivers by Moudy Al-Rashid

The rivers are the Tigris and the Euphrates. It was between these two rivers that civilisation started. The first cities, the first writing, the first schools, the first bureaucracies. And because the Mesopotamians wrote everything down on clay tablets, what they wrote has survived much better than later civilisations that wrote on more perishable mediums. But it’s one thing digging up these cuneiform tablets, it’s another thing reading them. The last native reader of Mesopotamian died thousands of years ago.

So it was a pretty big deal when cuneiform was deciphered. But where the story differs from Egyptian hiergoglyphs (which were also a big deal when they were translated) is how many cuneiform tablets have survived. University departments have cupboards full of the things, waiting someone to come and read them.

Al-Rashid does an excellent job of conveying the excitement of discovery and she makes the point, repeatedly, that despite the gulf in time that separates us, the people who wrote, or figured in, these rediscovered writings were people like us. I do think she overeggs that point: yes, they were human, so they share the basic hopes, fears and dreams that unite humanity but it would have been more interesting to learn more about how they differed, for differ they surely did. Their mental and spiritual landscape was very different from ours, as indeed was their geography.

In the end, this is a book that conveys the author’s passion for a subject very well but, unfortunately, at least for me, it didn’t convey much of the actual subject.

Book review: An Infinite Summer by Christopher Priest

An Infinite Summer by Christopher Priest

Christopher Priest, he dead. He died in February 2024. He will now know time from a different angle. I look forward to reading those stories! It’s perhaps no surprise that another Christopher, Nolan, for whom time is just as much an obsession adapted one of Priest’s novels, The Prestige, into a film.

The title story in the collection, the first, best illustrates Priest’s understanding of time, when one of a pair of young Victorian lovers is caught, and suspended, in an eternal moment in summer and her lover, still caught in time’s flow, returns to the place and the moment hoping to see her.

Perception, being cousin to time, is another Priest concern, as depicted in the final novella, ‘The Watched’, set on an island where everything is watched. Does time flow when no one is watching it?

These are strange, spare, fascinating stories that hint at much without necessarily having more to say than the words on the paper. The time and the perception of the reader, his or her interaction with the words, are what make these stories, or unmake them: for you, they may be as dull and lifeless as yesterday’s newspapers or as vivid and unsettling as being part of today’s news.

Book review: The World of Late Antiquity by Peter Brown

The World of Late Antiquity by Peter Brown

It’s a rare book that transforms a field of study. This is one of those rare books. For two hundred years, the study of the fourth to the eighth centuries had lived in the long, long shadow of Edward Gibbon’s The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. Gibbon was both a great writer and a great historian; according to his work, the ruins of Empire that the aristocrats who went round Europe on the Grand Tour saw in Rome and other stops along the way told the story of a lost civilisation that had fallen when the barbarians took over, bringing in a new age of darkness that endured until, well, Gibbon himself.

It took Peter Brown to point out the problem with this: the Empire didn’t fall. Yes, in the West, Rome itself was captured by barbarians but for more than a century before that, Rome hadn’t been the capital of the Empire: that was Constantinople. And Constantinople didn’t fall. Its emperors regarded themselves as the rulers of the Roman Empire and the citizens of his Empire saw themselves as Romans. Meanwhile, in the West, the new barbarian kings were rapidly adopting all they could of the old Empire.

Brown’s genius was to look at the changes that occurred between the fourth and eighth centuries as change and transformation rather than decline and fall. As such, he unlocked a completely new vision of this period of history. While the decline and fall narrative still holds some explanatory value (particularly in Britain), the change and transformation makes much more sense in the eastern Mediterranean as well as helping us understand exactly what these incoming barbarians wanted when they arrived.

It also helps that Peter Brown is as accomplished a writer as Edward Gibbon – and that’s high praise indeed!

Book review: Mythago Wood by Robert Holdstock

Mythago Wood by Robert Holdstock

Have you ever walked, alone, in an English wood at twilight? That’s the genius of the book’s central idea because anyone walking in one of England’s old woods when the day is done but night not yet come will have felt the shadow of the years and the whisper of tales following them in the hush when the birds settle and the wood…waits. That’s the quiet before the story starts, the pause before the first breath, the stop before the fall.

As such, for any who have walked in such woods, it must come as something almost obvious that these woods contain things unseen, that they stretch away to places unwalked, and that they hold mysteries. That’s the central idea of Mythago Wood: that myths come from the wood, made real, flesh and blood but still myth, and that the wood itself is, like the Tardis, bigger on the inside than the outside.

What the book of the wood does, and does really well, is convey this idea of ‘wood’ as birthing pool and whirlpool, as a place of danger and refuge, of enchantment and chains. What it doesn’t do particularly well is tell a story or portray characters. Of the characters in the book, only Stephen, the protagonist, and his brother and antagonist emerge as real characters; Guiwinneth, their joint love interest, bears all the irritating mark of a female character whom the (male) author has fallen in love with himself.

As for the story, it shares the disjointedness of dream, which is appropriate given the subject matter, but disappointing, given the necessities of narrative. Myths may spring from the unconscious woodland but they are formed and given shape in the light. Here, we get the myth too raw for true art but raw enough to let one slip, for a moment perhaps, when putting the book down at the end of the day, into the hinterland of that Great Wood of story that lies on the edge of our world and others.

Book review: Dark Frontier by Matthew Harffy

Dark Frontier by Matthew Harffy

Matthew and I are friends. But friendship notwithstanding, he’s also a bloody good writer and Dark Frontier exemplifies that. Unlike Matthew’s other historical fiction, which is set in the early medieval, Dark Frontier takes place a thousand years later and in a land that the protagonists of his other books didn’t even know existed. But, as Matthew once said to me, his other books are really Westerns in disguise and, for this book, the disguise comes off!

But Matthew has the authorial nous to know that we, the readers, are not necessarily familiar with life in Oregon at the end of the 19th century. To bridge the gap, Matthew makes the hero not one of the laconic cowboys who inhabit that landscape naturally but a travelling Englishman, a London detective escaping his past. That naturally gives us an outsider’s perspective on the action, which is one we share as readers who don’t live or know the time and place we’re visiting, and it’s a bit of a masterstroke. Gabriel Stokes serves as everyman as well as protagonist and hero, allowing us into the story alongside him, and introducing us to this new world.

As for the world, Matthew writes about it as if he grew up in the saddle rather than in Sunderland (OK, I’m not sure exactly where he grew up, but it was somewhere up north and Sunderland allows for alliteration!). This is a great addition to Matthew’s formidable library of stories and I hope he will write many more Westerns. The genre is due for a rediscovery and Matthew might just be the man to do it.

Book review: Orkneying Saga: the History of the Earls of Orkney

Orkneying Saga: The History of the Earls of Orkney

There’s a lot of fighting in this book. The Earls of Orkney seem to have spent most of their waking hours falling out with relatives, being deposed, sailing off to Norway to enlist the help of the King of Norway, sailing back, trying, and sometimes succeeding, in displacing the new earl, and then the whole cycle repeats itself.

As a narrative it stretches on with not too much to distinguish the different earls. But as a historical document it’s fascinating. Thinking oneself into the minds of the men who led these lives requires a rethinking of most of the unwritten assumptions that underlie our everyday lives today, from the value or otherwise of each life, through to attitudes to danger, the importance of glory, whether temper should be controlled or allowed to run into revenge, and much else besides. Really, it was a different world.

Perhaps that difference is best encapsulated in the history of the Earl Rognvald Kali who decides to go off on Crusade, sets off to the Holy Land accompanied by a retinue of poets, gets there, fights for Byzantium, and then comes back and gets killed walking through the wrong door. The history pretty much ends with him. Fascinating but frustrating. What a time – and thank goodness I didn’t live in it!

Book review: Barrowbeck by Andrew Michael Hurley

Barrowbeck by Andrew Michael Hurley

This is my first tilt at the new genre that’s making literary waves at the moment: folk horror. Which basically seems to mean creepy and slightly unsettling stories set in the British countryside with a strong descriptive vein running through them. Folk horror might be the new marketing term but really it’s a continuation of a long running vein of English writing: the stories in Barrowbeck are not so dissimilar in feel to the stories EF Benson wrote in the 1920s and ’30s, although Benson’s speciality was out-of-season English seaside resorts, which have their own thread of peculiar disquiet running through them even if nothing out of the way happens at all. Another influence is the film The Wicker Man, although without the 1970s sex that runs through the movie.

Hurley is an ambitious and atmospheric writer and the stories are well crafted and succeed in doing what he sets them to do. So I am trying to work out why it didn’t really work for me. There’s no lack of craft, quite the opposite. The stories do manage to hint at the unsettling and the out of kilter, suggesting rather than exemplifying. I think my problem is Barrowbeck itself. The stories are spread through time, from the village’s foundation to the near future, with the village and the valley in which it is set the only ongoing character. I think that’s where the problem lies. Barrowbeck. It doesn’t ring right with me. It’s supposed to be a dead end village at the end of a valley that no one visits. But it’s simply too big, has too many houses, shops, everything: it’s not a village, it’s a town of indeterminate and shifting size in a place where, we’re told, there’s only a village. Many that’s part of the story, that Barrowbeck itself is indeterminate, that it shifts. But I don’t think it is meant to be like that.

So, for me, that’s why the stories don’t quite work. It’s not the stories, it’s the place. But I do think the book is worth reading. If you do read it, let me know if you agree or disagree with me.

Book review: The Keep by F Paul Wilson

The Keep by F Paul Wilson

An interesting idea that ultimately chickens out of really going somewhere interesting. The premise is that a garrison of German soldiers stationed in a lonely castle in Transylvania start getting murdered by some sort of supernatural being.

What would have made the story really interesting would have been playing with the idea of who should one, as a reader, identify with in this scenario: the monster or the Germans. But unfortunately Wilson doesn’t have the courage of where the idea should have really taken him, in making the German commander the protagonist and ‘hero’. It would have been even more interesting to make the commander of the SS detachment that comes in to sort out the problem the protagonist. Unfortunately, we get a more normal hero, in a semi-supernatural vampire killer, and it all gets fairly predictable thereafter. But imagine the genuine discomfort of a book where you don’t know who is the real monster (which would have required not chickening out the other way and making the vampire sympathetic). Now that would have been a really interesting book. This book, however, is competent but nothing more.

Book review: The Penguin Book of the Renaissance by JH Plumb

The Penguin Book of the Renaissance by JH Plumb

I’ve long suspected that the Renaissance was basically a scam that the Italians managed to pull on the rest of Europe, an orchestrated campaign to convince everyone else that their newly adopted styles of art and architecture were a la mode, a sort of early version of FOMO. It’s clear that Professor Plumb, the editor and contributor to this volume, doesn’t agree. He’s a true partisan of the Renaissance, quite convinced that Corinthian columns beat Gothic arches every time. I must say that I prefer Gothic, with its wild designs, its yearning, its openness to transcendence, over the Renaissance gaze at the human, usually naked and over muscled, like a modern gym.

However, given by prejudice against the Renaissance, reading something by a partisan for it was a necessary corrective, and this book does an excellent job of providing an overview of how the Italians managed to transform art and architecture in the Quattrocento, and then spread that everywhere else.

Book review: Echoes by Will Sergeant

Echoes by Will Sergeant

I strongly suspect that Sergeant started writing the first volume of his memoirs, Bunnyman, during the Covid restrictions. I think he wrote this one after we were allowed out into the world once again, blinking and wide eyed. Bunnyman had something of the same atmosphere of restriction and closed-off horizons, although those were a feature of Sergeant’s 1970s upbringing – something I recognise myself. There’s only a few years between us and while he lived in Liverpool and I in London, there wasn’t so much difference between the two cities then.

They did, however, diverge markedly from the 1980s onwards. Echoes picks up the story with the Bunnymen making their first album, the growing importance and recognition of the Liverpool scene (Julian Cope, Pete Wylie, etc) and the sudden proliferation of record labels. Yes, the Bunnymen were talented but reading this memoir, it did all rather fall into their laps. To give them credit, they made the most of the opportunity, and produced one of the all time best debut albums in Crododiles (I can see you’ve got the blues in your alligator shoes/Me, I’m all smiles, I got my crocodiles).

For anyone, like me, who read NME, Melody Maker and Sounds through the early 80s, it’s a trip behind the curtain and through the words on the page to what was happening with the bands we were following. The Bunnymen were, for a while, the best band in the world. This covers the start of that period and for anyone who was around at the time and into this music, it’s a great reminder of when music really was the most important thing in life.